The homemade apple pie of my early childhood was enveloped in a flaky lard crust. After my grandmothers retired from baking, my mom—and it seemed like everyone else—succumbed to the ease of grocery store freezer-section pies. For holidays, a local bakery pie might come to the table. None had the flavor and texture of the old days, but I didn’t know what was missing. On my 1977 visit to Santa Fe, I was treated to dinner at the venerable Pink Adobe. The combo plate was satisfying, but the pie dazzled me. Cinnamon-scented apple slices were surrounded by the crust of my childhood. I discovered that lard was the secret to adding flakiness and an elusive savoriness to the crust. Most pie recipes say it’s fine to substitute a store-bought crust but it’s not fine. Go to the effort to make your own and find yourself transported.
Why Use Lard in Pie Crust?
Lard is what gives an old-fashioned crust its flakiness and its subtle, savory edge. Fat in pie dough melts in the oven and releases steam, which puffs the dough into layers. Lard has a different crystal structure than butter, and it stays solid over a wider range of temperatures, so it creates especially tender, flaky layers. A little butter adds flavor and color, and vegetable shortening makes the dough easier to handle. Look for leaf lard or high-quality rendered lard at a butcher shop, since shelf-stable lard can taste flat.
Whatever you do, skip the store-bought crust for this one. Homemade takes only a few minutes in a food processor, and the difference is worth it.
What Are the Best Apples for Apple Pie?
Use a mix of tart and sweet apples for the most complex flavor. Tart, firm apples like Granny Smith and Northern Spy hold their shape and add brightness. Sweeter varieties like Honeycrisp, Golden Delicious, Braeburn, and Jonagold add juice and fragrance. Avoid very soft apples, like McIntosh, on their own, since they collapse into applesauce. Slice the apples thinly and evenly, about ¼ inch thick, so they bake at the same rate.
How Do You Make Classic Apple Pie?
Pulse the flour and salt in a food processor. Add the butter, then the lard and shortening, and pulse until blended. Add ice water a little at a time until the dough holds together, then divide it into two disks and chill. Roll out one disk, fit it into a greased nine-inch pie pan, and roll out the second for the top. Chill both crusts while you make the filling.
Mix the sugar and cornstarch, and sprinkle half into the bottom crust. Toss the apples with the rest of the sugar mixture, the brown sugar, the spices, salt, and lemon juice, and pile them into the crust. Dot the filling with butter, add the top crust, crimp the edges, and cut vents. Brush the top with milk or egg white and sprinkle it with coarse sugar.
Bake at 375 degrees for 10 minutes, then lower the oven to 350 degrees and bake until the crust is golden and the filling bubbles through the vents.
Why Is My Apple Pie Runny?
A runny pie is usually underbaked. The cornstarch has to boil to thicken, so bake until you see the filling bubbling through the vents, not just until the crust is brown. Then let the pie cool for at least an hour, ideally longer, so the juices set. Very juicy apples need a little more cornstarch, about one extra teaspoon.
Can I Make Apple Pie Ahead?
Yes. Make the dough up to two days ahead and refrigerate it, or freeze it for up to three months. A baked apple pie keeps, loosely covered, at room temperature for up to two days. To freeze an unbaked pie, wrap it tightly and freeze it for up to three months, then bake it from frozen at 375 degrees, adding 20 to 30 minutes.
How Do I Make This Apple Pie Gluten-Free or Dairy-Free?
Gluten-free: Use a 1-to-1 gluten-free baking flour with xanthan gum in the crust, and roll the dough between sheets of parchment.
Dairy-free: Replace the butter in the crust with more lard or shortening, dot the filling with plant-based butter, and brush the top with egg white instead of milk.
Tips for Success
Keep the fats very cold. Cube them and chill them until you’re ready to use them.
Don’t stretch the dough. Ease it into the pan, or it will shrink in the oven.
Catch the drips. Set a foil-lined pan on the rack below the pie.
Shield the edges. Cover the rim with foil, then remove it for the last 20 minutes so it browns.
What Can I Serve With Apple Pie?
Vanilla ice cream is the classic, but a slice of sharp cheddar is a delicious old-school pairing. Pour hot coffee or a glass of hard cider.
For more apple desserts, bake Amy Price’s Dutch Apple Pie with a Twist and browse our Apple Recipes to Embrace the Fall Season.Â
Cheryl’s Cranberry Orange Fig Compote and Winter White Pavlova round out a holiday menu.Â
Find more in Dessert Recipes to Fill the Thanksgiving Table and all of our holiday pie recipes.
Recipe adapted from American Home Cooking © 1999 Cheryl Alters Jamison and Bill Jamison
About the Recipe Developer
Cheryl Alters Jamison | Contributing Editor. This four-time James Beard award-winner moved from the Midwest to the Southwest more than 40 years ago, in search of chile-laced food and ski slopes. Her 20 cookbooks include Tasting New Mexico, The Rancho de Chimayó Cookbook, and The Border Cookbook. She works with Hutton Broadcasting, hosting the weekly food radio show Heating It Up. Read more of her recipes at TABLE.
About the Stylists
Merrie O’Donnell is a stylist whose work appears in TABLE Magazine.
Keith Recker is editor in chief and co-owner of TABLE Magazine, directing coverage of food and drink, design, fashion, travel, and the arts across its Pittsburgh and New Mexico editions. A color and trend forecaster for clients including Pantone and WGSN, he is the author of three books on color and craft, most recently Deep Color: The Shades That Shape Our Souls. Read Keith’s articles.
About the Photographer
Dave Bryce is TABLE Magazine’s principal photographer. Known for images that explore depth and dimension through space and light, he is also a commercial and editorial food photographer who works closely with chefs and food stylists. Meet TABLE’s contributors.
Subscribe to TABLE Magazine‘s print edition.
