Fill Your Holiday Table With Homemade Pies From Santa Fe Bakers

What would a Thanksgiving feast be without a perfect pumpkin pie—smooth, creamy, and cradled in a flaky crust, topped with whipped cream or ice cream? Imagine Christmas dinner with no pecan pie, that sinfully sweet combo of rich buttery nuts in a gooey filling.

Where to Grab Homemade Holiday Pies From Santa Fe Bakers

Homemade holiday pies are an integral part of the celebratory meal, often upstaging the turkey, the ham, and even the sides. If you find, amid all the hoopla of the holiday season, that your plans to bake a pie are just pie in the sky, consider two go-to Santa Fe sources of delectable desserts.

Chase Maus at Paloma

Chase Maus, acclaimed pastry chef at Paloma, hails from Kentucky, where he co-owned Rose & Mary Bakery in Covington. His southern heritage shines in his mouthwatering desserts, especially his Meemaw’s pie. “I bake it now in the form of a toasted coconut chess pie,” says Maus, who made it to the Season 12 final of the Food Network’s Holiday Baking Championship series. The chess pie won him the first challenge on the show. “It’s become my favorite pie. I love the classics for the holidays, but this pie is unbeatable. I love how custardy it is, I love that it doesn’t need to be adorned with a lot of different things. It’s chess pie, and it comes from the simplest ingredients: eggs, sugar, cream, butter, and that is truly it.”

To order pies from Chase Maus, message @maus_chase.

A pie with torched meringue and a golden crust sits on a table beside a pile of forks, plates, and limes.

Santa Fe Bite

Santa Fe Bite is world-famous for its green chile cheeseburgers, but its handmade pies get a lot of love, too. “Everything is done in-house—the crust, filling, and baking,” says restaurant co-owner Angela Mason. The pies are made by Maribel Ortiz, who started at the restaurant as a food runner and now is their champion baker. While traditional pumpkin and pecan pies are their holiday staples, other sweet temptations have garnered fans. “We also offer for Thanksgiving and Christmas all of our cream pies—banana cream, coconut cream, chocolate cream, and Key Lime pie,” Mason says. “People just love our banana cream pie,” she says. “It’s not a traditional holiday pie, but it’s so popular.”

To order pies from Santa Fe Bite at least 48 hours in advance, call 505-428-0328.

Story by Lynn Cline

About the Photographer

Tira Howard is a Contributing Editor for TABLE Magazine New Mexico. Tira thrives on creating images at the intersection of food and fashion. The beauty of food and the people who feed us is endlessly inspiring to her and guides her photography into the realm of emotion and storytelling.

Subscribe to TABLE Magazine’s print edition.

SUBSCRIBE TO TABLE TALK

We respect your privacy.

Related Articles

Shop Local: A Look Into Holiday Gift Ideas From New Mexico Shops and Makers

The holidays are on the horizon — here's where inspiration begins.

This Year’s Fred Harvey History Weekend Celebrates 150 Years of Legacy

Fred Harvey History Weekend brings the story of one of the American West’s most influential hospitality companies to life through a weekend of talks, tours, and memorable experiences.

Vanna Curated Living in Santa Fe: Where Art, Culture & Community Meet

Step inside Vanna Curated Living in Santa Fe, a unique gallery where art, culture, history, and meaningful connections come together.